Scottish Bill loses weapon and shield

02 June 2015

The Charity, Electrical Safety First, is worried that the Government’s proposed Scotland Bill, which will devolve further powers to the Scottish Parliament, has forgotten consumer protection - and a weapon to curb the tide of counterfeits entering the UK.

Commenting on the Bill, Phil Buckle, Director-General of Electrical Safety First said:
“There has been a huge increase in counterfeit and sub-standard electrical goods entering the UK – particularly Scotland. In the five years between 2008 and 2013, Glasgow enforcement agencies seized more fake electrical items than any other UK local authority. When you realise that around two thirds of all domestic fires in Scotland are caused by electricity and the vast majority of those arise from electrical products, you can put the situation in context.

“We believe people would be best served by devolving consumer protection powers to the Scottish Government to deal with the issues ‘on the ground’ – and as recommended last month, by a cross-party committee of the Scottish Parliament.”

In its current form, the Scotland Bill only allows consumer advocacy and advice to be devolved to Scotland, with control over the legal framework of consumer protection retained by Westminster. Electrical Safety First believes consumer protection should be transferred to the Scottish Parliament, which would then have the power to tackle the issues of electrical product safety and prevention of fires in Scottish homes. This would also allow a Scottish Government to respond to the need for changes to the product recall system – which research by Electrical Safety First shows is failing to protect consumers.

“Recent tragic accidents, where individuals have died through electric shock or an electric fire caused by a recalled product, have highlighted the need to improve the way such products are recalled by manufacturers”, adds Phil Buckle. “And with well over 200 electrical items recalled in the last four years - but with a recall success rate of only 10 -20% - it is clear the current system needs improvement. This is especially important for Scotland, where so many domestic fires are caused by electrical products.”

For more information on Electrical Safety First and to view our Scottish Manifesto, please go to:


Editor’s Notes:
Further information can be found at -

For further media information, please contact:

Angela Murphy – Tel. 020 3463 5127

Wayne Mackay – Tel. 01582 539138